When it comes to securing a building, facility or other area that needs to be protected, choosing the right type of fencing is an important decision and one which you must get right in order to achieve the right level of protection for your needs.
Whether you’re safeguarding a commercial site, industrial property, or a utility installation, two of the most popular perimeter fencing options are mesh and palisade fencing. Both have their own strengths and are well-suited for different applications, but how do you decide which one is best suited for your needs? Well, that’s where this blog post can help you! We’ll compare mesh and palisade fencing solutions, examining their key features, benefits, and ideal use cases to help you make an informed decision.
Firstly, let’s start by taking a look at what mesh and palisade fencing actually are.
What Is Mesh Fencing?
This is often referred to as ‘welded wire mesh’, and sometimes ‘chain link’ fencing, consists of wire mesh panels that are secured between posts. The most common types include V-mesh, twin-wire mesh, and chain link, each providing varying levels of security based on the thickness and pattern of the wire used in the design of the fence.
What Is Palisade Fencing?
This is a high-security solution that’s commonly manufactured using steel or iron pales, which are vertically aligned and secured to horizontal rails. The top of each pale is typically shaped into a pointed spear or blunt tip to help deter climbing. You will often find this type of fencing helping to protect more valuable assets when compared with mesh option.
The Benefits
Now that you have a basic understanding of what palisade and mesh fencing are, let’s take a look at the numerous benefits associated with each type.
Mesh Fencing
- Visibility – Due to its apertures and the gauge of wire used, it provides excellent visibility, making it ideal for areas where surveillance through the barrier is important. This makes it easier to spot intruders or suspicious activity from a distance and on both sides of the fence.
- Cost-Effective – Generally speaking, mesh fencing is more affordable than palisade, both in terms of material costs and installation. When you factor in ongoing maintenance however, this may paint a different picture as palisade option is considered more durable over time.
- Customisation Options – Mesh is often available in various heights and different gauges of wire, allowing you to choose the right balance between visibility and security. You will often be able to choose the colour of the finish and other customisation options.
- Flexible Use – Mesh fencing can be used for various purposes, from perimeter security to animal enclosures and sports grounds. Its flexibility makes it a highly versatile choice for a wide range of settings.
- Non-Aggressive Appearance – If aesthetics matter, as is often the case in public spaces, then mesh fencing offers a cleaner, less intimidating look compared to palisade. This can be especially important for schools, parks, and residential areas.
Palisade Fencing
- High Security – This is one of the most robust and formidable options available. The solid metal pales are difficult to cut through or climb over, making it an excellent choice for high-security installations. Whilst some manufacturers of mesh fencing solutions such as Lochrin Bain offer a range of high security mesh options, their high security palisade fencing options will often be able to offer better levels of protection.
- Durability – Made from steel, palisade fencing is highly resistant to impact and environmental wear and tear, offering a long-lasting solution for sites that require heavy-duty security. When finished with a galvanized coating and optional powder coated finish, you can enhance the durability of your palisade fence even further and benefit from better protection against the elements including salt spray which can lead to corrosion.
- Deterrence – Its spiked tops and imposing design are strong visual deterrents that help to discourage potential intruders from attempting to breach the fence in the first place.
- Minimal Maintenance – Steel palisade requires very little maintenance once installed, thanks to its corrosion-resistant materials. This makes it a cost-effective solution in the long run when compared to mesh fencing which will often come with shorter guarantees.
When to Choose Mesh Fencing
So, there we have the benefits of both types of fences. Let’s now take a look at why you might choose mesh fencing over steel palisade.
When you need moderate security combined with visibility and affordability, mesh may be the answer. If you’re looking to secure a school playground, sports field, or residential property where aesthetics and upfront cost are more important than security, then mesh fencing is ideal as it allows for clear sightlines and a non-threatening appearance while still offering decent protection at a sensible price point.
Additionally, mesh fencing can sometimes be easier to install over flat ground and can be adapted for various applications, making it a flexible solution for areas that may not require high-level security.
When to Choose Palisade Fence
Considered the go-to option for environments where security is paramount, steel palisade fencing is often used to protect sensitive areas like industrial sites, military bases, and utility installations. If preventing access is your primary concern, palisade fencing is likely to offer the highest level of protection.
While it comes with a higher upfront cost and a more intimidating appearance, the trade-off is worth it for businesses and organisations that need to ensure intruders stay out. Palisade fencing is also extremely durable and resistant to environmental factors, meaning it will serve its purpose for many years to come with little to no maintenance requirements.
Conclusion – Which Is Best?
The decision between mesh and palisade fencing comes down to your specific circumstances. If you are looking for a more affordable, flexible, and aesthetically pleasing perimeter fencing option with moderate security, then mesh option is your best friend! However, if high-level security, durability, and a strong visual deterrent are what you’re after, then palisade fencing is the better choice.
You should always consider the nature of what you’re looking to protect, the level of risk, and your budget before making your final decision. Both fencing types offer excellent protection in their own ways, so it’s all about finding the right fit for your particular situation.
